2 Beef Wellington Recipes: Which One Fits Your Kitchen Skills?
2 Beef Wellington Recipes: Which One Fits Your Kitchen Skills?
VS
2 recipes

2 Beef Wellington Recipes: Which One Fits Your Kitchen Skills?

2 レシピを比較更新 2026/5/11ChefChef が分析

These two Beef Wellington versions offer distinct paths to the classic British centerpiece, ranging from total scratch-cooking to clever structural hacks. Binging with Babish takes a 'Mad Men' inspired approach, demanding a 6-hour commitment to hand-laminated puff pastry and a side of Napoleons. In contrast, Joshua Weissman focuses on structural integrity by using savory crepes to protect the pastry from mushroom moisture. Both utilize beef tenderloin and mushroom duxelles, but differ significantly in their choice of deglazing spirits—Cognac versus Whiskey—and their overall complexity. Readers will learn how to manage pastry hydration and the importance of the resting phase for a perfect medium-rare finish.

レシピ

Comprehensive Recipe: Beef Wellington and Napoleons (Mad Men Style) by Binging with Babish

Comprehensive Recipe: Beef Wellington and Napoleons (Mad Men Style)

A high-effort, purist approach featuring completely scratch-made puff pastry and a bonus Napoleon dessert.

調理時間
Approx. 5-6 hours (including pastry chilling time)
人数
4-6 servings
難易度
難しい

主な材料

2 cups + extra for dusting All-purpose flour (for pastry and butter block) · 2 sticks Unsalted butter (cold) · 1 cup Ice water · approx. 2-3 lbs Beef tenderloin roast · 1/4 lb Prosciutto … +13

レシピ全文を見る →
Perfect Beef Wellington by Joshua Weissman

Perfect Beef Wellington

Focuses on structural perfection using a crepe barrier to prevent sogginess and a beautiful lattice pastry design.

調理時間
Approximately 2-3 hours (including chilling time)
人数
Serves 4-6
難易度
普通

主な材料

1.5 pound (650g) Beef tenderloin (center cut) · 2 tablespoons (24ml) High heat oil (like canola) · to taste Salt and pepper · for brushing Good Dijon mustard · 1.5 sheets Puff pastry … +13

レシピ全文を見る →

材料の違い

Comprehensive Recipe: Beef Wellington and Napoleons (Mad Men Style) (Binging with Babish)

Uses 2 sticks of cold butter and ice water for scratch-made puff pastry; deglazes mushrooms with Cognac and adds heavy cream.

Perfect Beef Wellington (Joshua Weissman)

Uses 1.5 sheets of prepared puff pastry and includes ingredients for savory crepes (milk, flour, eggs) to act as a moisture barrier.

作り方の違い

Comprehensive Recipe: Beef Wellington and Napoleons (Mad Men Style) (Binging with Babish)

Requires a 5-6 hour process including manual pastry lamination and tempering egg yolks for a separate pastry cream.

Perfect Beef Wellington (Joshua Weissman)

Employs a 'crepe-wrap' technique to shield the pastry and features a decorative lattice top for a professional visual finish.

味の違い

Comprehensive Recipe: Beef Wellington and Napoleons (Mad Men Style) (Binging with Babish)

Rich and buttery with a classic French profile from the Cognac-infused duxelles and sharp English mustard.

Perfect Beef Wellington (Joshua Weissman)

Features a subtle smokiness from whiskey and a more complex textural contrast provided by the thin crepe layer and flaky salt.

おすすめ

Choose Babish if you are a culinary purist looking for a full-day weekend project that includes a scratch-made dessert. Opt for Weissman if you want a reliable, structurally sound Wellington with a professional lattice look in half the time.